RC 

Reading handout

Lula, the great survivor, makes history

1

Words to know

bellwether

BELL-weth-er

Quote from the article

“a 42-year old evangelical congressman from Minas Gerais, Brazil’s bellwether state”

Meaning:A bellwether is something whose behaviour is a good early sign of what will happen more widely. The word comes from shepherds, who hung a bell on the lead sheep (a wether) so the flock would follow it. In politics, a bellwether state or town is one whose voters tend to land on the winning side, so watching it tells you how the whole country may vote. The article calls Minas Gerais Brazil's bellwether state for exactly that reason.

More examples

  • Ohio was long treated as a bellwether in American presidential races, since it usually backed the eventual winner.
  • The sneaker store's sales are a bellwether for what teenagers will be wearing next season.

annul

uh-NUL

Quote from the article

“said he would try to get the election result annulled”

Meaning:To annul something is to declare officially that it was never valid, wiping it out as if it had never happened. Courts annul marriages and contracts, and in politics a result can be annulled if a body with the power finds it was unfair or illegal. Here Mr Bolsonaro, having lost, says he will try to get the whole election result thrown out, even though the article notes that he himself had asked for the longer voting hours he now complains about.

More examples

  • The judge agreed to annul the contract because one side had been tricked into signing it.
  • The school threatened to annul the race results if anyone was found to have cheated.

lavish

LAV-ish

Quote from the article

“Incumbents in Brazil often make lavish giveaways before elections”

Meaning:Lavish describes something given or spent in very generous, even extravagant amounts: a lavish party, a lavish gift. It often hints that the generosity goes beyond what is sensible. In the article, Brazil's leaders routinely hand out big benefits before a vote to win favour, and the Economist says Lula's giveaways were generous even by that standard, which could cost the government dearly later.

More examples

  • For her birthday, her uncle threw a lavish party with a live band and three cakes.
  • The mayor was criticised for lavish spending on a new stadium while the roads fell apart.
2

Concepts behind the story

The run-off election

Quote from the article

“No presidential hopeful since the return of democracy in 1985 had lost the first round and won the run-off.”

Civics. In the US, the candidate with the most electoral votes wins, so a crowded field rarely matters. Brazil does it differently. In the first round many candidates compete. If nobody gets more than half the votes, the top two face each other in a run-off a few weeks later, so the winner always has a majority.

That changes the game. Voters whose favourite was knocked out must pick between the finalists or stay home. In this election, the candidates eliminated in round one together held 8% of votes and backed Flávio Bolsonaro, who was already ahead, so Lula looked in trouble. But a run-off is a brand-new contest: Lula had three weeks to change his campaign and win over people who had not voted or had spoiled their ballots (cast them invalidly) the first time. He gained about 10m votes and won 52% to 48%.

A second round rewards the candidate who can persuade the other side's doubters, not just excite their own fans.

When a country holds a run-off, remember that the first-round leader is only the favourite, not the winner.

Real interest rates and government debt

Quote from the article

“the central bank has hiked real interest rates to vertigo-inducing heights. The ratio of government debt to GDP rose by over ten percentage points in Lula’s last four years in office.”

Economics. When you borrow, you pay interest. A real interest rate is the interest rate after subtracting inflation (the rise in prices), so it shows the true cost of borrowing. If a loan charges 15% and prices rise 5%, the real rate is about 10%, which is very high.

A central bank (the institution that sets a country's key interest rate) raises rates to cool prices when spending runs hot. A government that spends more than it collects has to borrow, and the debt-to-GDP ratio compares what it owes to the size of the whole economy, like comparing a family's debts to its yearly income. When rates are high, the interest on that debt grows heavier, so spending and borrowing feed each other.

That is why the article says Lula should pick a respected finance minister and a credible plan to cut spending: investors lending to Brazil want proof the debt will not balloon. Free-spending promises before the election suggest he might do the opposite, which could keep borrowing costs high.

When you hear that a country's borrowing costs are high, ask how much it owes compared with what its economy earns.